The Sahabas Do Forget Hadeeses

The Sunnies are of the opinion that the Holy Sahabas and the narrators of hadees are immune to any type of sins and errors and they do not commit any mistake or errors while transmitting Hadeeses. 

But unfortunately they do not hold the same opinion about the Holy Prophet (saww) himself.

Below I quote a reference from the fourth Volume 4 Page No. 25 of the Urdu edition of Musnad of Ahamd Ibne Hanbal  to prove my point.

Witch doctor Abu Hurera (lnati) says that " Once the Holy Prophet (saww) while reciting one of the two night prayers (which the witch doctor Abu Hurera Lanati  had conveyed but the narrator Mohammed forgot) completed the prayers after reciting only two rakats..............

The above narration makes clear that the sub narrator forgot to exactly convey the hadees as was narrated to him and according to witch doctor aaira gira Abu Huraira the Holy Prophet (saww) did forget a part of prayers (Astagfirullah)

Now if the Sunnis say that this tradition is correct then it puts a question mark on the narration of Ahadees as it negates their premise that narrators do not commit a mistake. And if they believe that God forbid the Holy Prophet (saww) can forget then so can the sahabas. Thus the Bukhari the Muslim and other books of Hadees loose their authenticity and hence sunni Islam comes down as a pack of cards.

If they believe that this hadees is incorrect then the witch doctor is questionable and it also puts a question mark on Imam Ahmad Ibne Hanbal and his Musnad. Here too the Sunni Islam is blown away as is hay in the strong wind.

IT'S A LOOSE LOOSE SITUATION FOR THE POOR POOR SUNNIES.....

Get the references below (Click on the image for a larger view).